Cangzhou Wings Of Liberty Sport Products Co., Ltd. Supplier Evaluation

Executive Summary

Cangzhou Wings Of Liberty Sport Products Co., Ltd. is a China-based supplier located in Hebei, focused on martial arts flooring products such as MMA tatami, judo mats, and jiu-jitsu/BJJ floor mats. Based on the provided data, the company operates from a factory area of over 4,000㎡ with more than 20 staff and is marked as a verified supplier, indicating a basic but relatively credible production foundation. Its profile shows 3 years as a Gold Supplier, Trade Assurance support, response time within 1 hour, full customization capability, and warranty availability. Commercially, the supplier has recorded 100+ orders and CN¥4.4M+ transaction value in the past six months, which suggests active market validation. However, the on-time delivery rate of 76.0% is a notable operational risk, and the store rating of 4.1 with 50+ reviews indicates moderate rather than strong customer satisfaction. This supplier is more suitable for buyers seeking customized martial arts mats with moderate order scale, while delivery control should be closely managed.

Detailed Analysis

1. Company Strength

Basis:
- Factory location: Hebei, China
- Factory area: 4,000+㎡
- Employees: 20+ staff
- Verified supplier: True
- Product scope: MMA tatami mats, judo mats, jiu-jitsu/BJJ floor mats

Elaboration:
The supplier has a physical factory footprint of more than 4,000㎡ and a workforce of over 20 employees. This indicates that the company has an established production base, though the employee size remains relatively modest. The provided product listings are concentrated in martial arts and combat sports flooring, which suggests category specialization rather than a broad unrelated product portfolio. The verified supplier status adds credibility to the company’s factory presence, but the available data does not include detailed production capacity, machinery, annual output, export markets, or factory audit scope.

Scoring Rationale:
The factory area is reasonable for a specialized mat supplier, and verified supplier status supports basic confidence in operational legitimacy. However, the staff size of 20+ suggests the company is not a large-scale manufacturer. Since there is no data on advanced production lines, monthly output, major factory certifications, or large workforce scale, it should not be scored as a large stable supply chain. It fits best as a small-to-medium supplier with verified basic manufacturing capability.

Final Score: 14 / 20

2. Platform & Compliance Credibility

Basis:
- Gold Supplier: True
- Gold Supplier duration: 3 years
- Trade Assurance: True
- Verified supplier: True
- Certification/industry labels: Warranty available, response time ≤1h, on-time delivery 76.0%, full customization

Elaboration:
The supplier has several important platform credibility indicators, including Gold Supplier status, 3 years of platform history, Trade Assurance support, and verified supplier status. These elements provide a basic level of buyer protection and platform-backed credibility. The listed labels also show service-related capabilities such as fast response, warranty availability, and customization. However, the provided data does not include third-party factory audit reports, ISO certification, product safety certifications, inspection certificates, or industry-specific compliance documentation.

Scoring Rationale:
The combination of Gold Supplier status, Trade Assurance, and verified supplier status represents a solid platform compliance foundation. The 3-year Gold Supplier history is credible but not long enough to be considered a long-established platform record. Certification label completeness is also limited because the data mainly shows platform/service labels rather than formal quality or compliance certifications. Therefore, the supplier performs well but does not reach the top credibility band.

Final Score: 16 / 20

3. Business Performance

Basis:
- Orders in past 6 months: 100+
- Transaction value in past 6 months: CN¥4.4M+
- Store rating: 4.1
- Reviews: 50+

Elaboration:
The supplier has generated over 100 orders and more than CN¥4.4M in transaction value in the past six months, showing measurable commercial activity and buyer traction. This level of recent transaction data suggests that the supplier is not merely a passive listing but has active sales performance on the platform. However, the store rating of 4.1 is moderate, and the review count of 50+ provides some validation but does not represent a large-scale review base.

Scoring Rationale:
The six-month order volume and transaction value are relatively strong and support confidence in business activity. However, the 4.1 rating limits the score because it indicates customer satisfaction is not at a high-performance level. The number of reviews is sufficient for basic reference but not extensive enough to fully validate consistent buyer experience across a large customer base. Overall, business performance is commercially active but not premium-level due to customer feedback limitations.

Final Score: 16 / 20

4. Service Capability

Basis:
- Communication response time: ≤1h
- Full customization: listed
- Warranty available: listed

Elaboration:
The supplier demonstrates strong service responsiveness, with a stated response time of within one hour. Full customization is also listed, which is relevant for buyers of martial arts mats that may require different sizes, colors, thicknesses, branding, or surface textures, though the provided data does not specify exact customization options. Warranty availability further supports after-sales service capability, but no details are provided regarding warranty duration, coverage terms, or claim process.

Scoring Rationale:
A response time of ≤1 hour meets the highest service response criterion, and full customization indicates stronger-than-basic buyer support. Since there is no detailed evidence on customization workflow, design support, sampling process, or after-sales execution, the score should be strong but not perfect. The service capability appears suitable for buyers needing fast communication and customized products.

Final Score: 9 / 10

5. Delivery Performance

Basis:
- On-time delivery rate: 76.0%

Elaboration:
The supplier’s delivery performance is the weakest area in the provided data. An on-time delivery rate of 76.0% falls into the 70–79% range, which indicates that a meaningful portion of orders may experience shipment delays. For procurement teams managing seasonal demand, project deadlines, sports facility installations, or retail inventory planning, this delivery rate requires attention.

Scoring Rationale:
According to the scoring standard, a 70–79% on-time delivery rate corresponds to 5–6 points. At 76.0%, the supplier is in the upper part of this band but still below the 80% threshold for a more reliable delivery score. This performance does not prevent cooperation, but it does require stronger order tracking, confirmed lead times, and delivery penalty or buffer arrangements.

Final Score: 6 / 10

6. Quality & Customer Feedback

Basis:
- Store rating: 4.1
- Reviews: 50+
- Verified supplier: True
- Finished Product Inspection: Insufficient Data
- Factory Verification: Verified supplier marked as True, but detailed factory verification scope is Insufficient Data

Elaboration:
The supplier has a store rating of 4.1 and more than 50 reviews, which provides some customer feedback visibility. The rating is acceptable but not high, suggesting that buyer experience may be mixed or only moderately positive. Verified supplier status gives some confidence in supplier authenticity, but the data does not confirm a Finished Product Inspection process, detailed factory verification report, product testing standards, or quality management certifications.

Scoring Rationale:
The rating and review count support basic customer validation, but the 4.1 score is not strong enough to indicate consistently high satisfaction. The absence of confirmed Finished Product Inspection and detailed quality assurance documentation limits confidence in systematic quality control. Because quality information is partial and customer feedback is moderate, the supplier should be scored in the middle range rather than the high-quality assurance band.

Final Score: 12 / 20

Total Score

Total Score: 73 / 100

• Company Strength: 14 / 20
• Platform & Compliance Credibility: 16 / 20
• Business Performance: 16 / 20
• Service Capability: 9 / 10
• Delivery Performance: 6 / 10
• Quality & Customer Feedback: 12 / 20

Procurement Recommendation

Cooperation is recommended with controlled risk management. Cangzhou Wings Of Liberty Sport Products Co., Ltd. is suitable for buyers seeking martial arts mats, judo mats, MMA tatami mats, and BJJ floor mats with customization needs and moderate procurement volume. The supplier shows credible platform backing, fast response, active recent transactions, and basic verified manufacturing capability.

The main risks are the 76.0% on-time delivery rate, moderate 4.1 store rating, limited review base, and insufficient data on Finished Product Inspection, formal quality certifications, and detailed factory verification scope. Buyers should confirm lead times, request pre-shipment inspection, clarify warranty terms, and start with trial or staged orders before scaling. The supplier has growth potential if it improves delivery reliability and strengthens quality documentation.