Lishui Queenstar Stationery Manufacturing Co., Ltd. Supplier Evaluation

Executive Summary

Lishui Queenstar Stationery Manufacturing Co., Ltd. is a Zhejiang-based stationery supplier with a reported factory area of 7,000+ sqm, 50+ staff, and verified supplier status. Its listed products focus on cute cartoon school supplies, erasers, and stationery gift sets, with relatively accessible MOQs ranging from 360 to 1,000 sets. The supplier demonstrates strong platform credibility through 9 years as an Gold Supplier, Trade Assurance support, and customization-related service tags including Full Customization, ODM service, and Minor Customization. However, commercial validation remains limited, with only 10+ orders and CN¥67.6K+ transaction value in the past six months, plus only 3 customer reviews despite a 4.6 store rating. Delivery performance is moderate at 85.7% on-time shipment. Overall, this supplier appears suitable for small to medium buyers seeking customizable stationery gift sets, but buyers should manage quality and delivery risks carefully due to limited feedback volume and incomplete quality inspection data.

Detailed Analysis

1. Company Strength

Basis

• Factory location: Zhejiang, China
• Factory area: 7,000+ sqm
• Employees: 50+ staff
• Verified supplier / factory audit status: True

Elaboration

The supplier has a measurable production base with a factory area exceeding 7,000 sqm, which indicates a physical manufacturing setup rather than a purely trading-oriented profile based on the provided data. The workforce of 50+ staff suggests basic to medium-scale operational capacity. The verified supplier status adds credibility to the existence and legitimacy of the business operation. However, the employee count is not large, and the provided data does not include production line numbers, annual output, machinery details, export volume, or capacity utilization.

Scoring Rationale

The supplier shows stronger-than-basic manufacturing capability due to its reported factory space and verified status. However, the scale does not clearly reach the level of a large-scale stable supply chain because the employee count is moderate and detailed production capacity data is not available. Therefore, it fits best within the “medium stable factory” range rather than the top tier.

Final Score

15 / 20

2. Platform & Compliance Credibility

Basis

• Gold Supplier: True
• Gold Supplier duration: 9 years
• Trade Assurance: True
• Verification status: True
• Certification / service tags: Full customization, ODM service available, Minor customization, Response time ≤3h

Elaboration

The supplier has a long platform history, with 9 years as a Gold Supplier. This is a positive credibility indicator because it reflects platform continuity over a significant period. Trade Assurance support further improves transaction security for buyers. The verified supplier status also strengthens platform-based trust. The available tags show customization and service capabilities, but the data does not provide evidence of specific product certifications, management system certifications, or third-party compliance certificates.

Scoring Rationale

The supplier has a strong platform credibility profile due to long Gold Supplier tenure, Trade Assurance, and verification status. However, the provided certification/tag information is more service-oriented than compliance-certification-oriented, and there is insufficient data on formal product or factory certifications. For this reason, the score is high but not maximum.

Final Score

18 / 20

3. Business Performance

Basis

• Orders in past 6 months: 10+
• Transaction value in past 6 months: CN¥67.6K+
• Store rating: 4.6
• Number of reviews: 3

Elaboration

The supplier has recorded recent platform activity, but the scale is relatively limited. A 6-month order count of 10+ and transaction value of CN¥67.6K+ indicate that business is active, yet not high-volume based on the provided figures. The store rating of 4.6 is positive, but the review base of only 3 reviews is too small to strongly validate customer satisfaction trends.

Scoring Rationale

The supplier has some commercial proof, but the order count, transaction value, and review quantity are all limited. The 4.6 rating supports a positive impression, yet the very low review count weakens reliability. This places the supplier in the lower-to-mid business validation range, rather than a stable high-performing supplier category.

Final Score

11 / 20

4. Service Capability

Basis

• Communication response time: ≤3h
• Service tags: Full customization, ODM service available, Minor customization

Elaboration

The supplier shows clear customization capability based on the provided platform tags. Full customization and ODM service availability indicate that the supplier may support buyer-specific product requirements within the listed stationery category. The response time of ≤3 hours is acceptable and suggests reasonable communication efficiency, although it does not reach the highest benchmark of ≤1 hour.

Scoring Rationale

The supplier has stronger service capability than a basic supplier due to full customization, ODM, and minor customization options. However, the response speed is ≤3 hours rather than ≤1 hour, so it does not qualify for the highest service score range. The score reflects solid but not top-tier service responsiveness.

Final Score

8 / 10

5. Delivery Performance

Basis

• On-time shipment rate: 85.7%

Elaboration

An on-time shipment rate of 85.7% indicates moderate delivery reliability. It falls within the 80–89% range, which is acceptable but not excellent. Buyers requiring strict delivery schedules should pay attention to this figure, especially for seasonal stationery, school supply, or gift set orders where shipment timing may be important.

Scoring Rationale

According to the scoring rule, an on-time delivery rate between 80% and 89% corresponds to 7–8 points. Since 85.7% is in the upper half of this range but still below 90%, the supplier receives a relatively favorable score within the medium delivery-performance band.

Final Score

8 / 10

6. Quality & Customer Feedback

Basis

• Store rating: 4.6
• Number of reviews: 3
• Verified supplier / factory audit status: True
• Finished Product Inspection: Insufficient Data

Elaboration

The supplier has a good store rating of 4.6, but the reliability of this rating is limited by the very small review base of only 3 reviews. Verified supplier status provides some quality-related credibility from a supplier verification perspective. However, the provided data does not confirm Finished Product Inspection, product testing procedures, quality control workflow, defect rate, or certification-backed quality assurance.

Scoring Rationale

The rating is positive, and verification status is helpful, but the limited number of reviews prevents strong customer-feedback validation. In addition, Finished Product Inspection information is not available, which creates uncertainty around systematic quality control. Therefore, the supplier should be considered as having basic-to-moderate quality assurance evidence rather than a fully validated quality profile.

Final Score

12 / 20

Total Score

Procurement Recommendation

Recommendation: Conditional cooperation recommended.

Lishui Queenstar Stationery Manufacturing Co., Ltd. is suitable for buyers looking for cute cartoon stationery, school supply sets, erasers, and stationery gift sets with relatively accessible MOQs. The supplier may be appropriate for small to medium procurement programs, especially where customization or ODM support is needed.

Suitable customer types:
- Small to medium stationery importers
- Promotional gift buyers sourcing low-MOQ stationery sets
- Buyers requiring customized cartoon-style school supplies
- Trial-order buyers using Trade Assurance

Main risks:
- Limited recent commercial validation: only 10+ orders and CN¥67.6K+ in the past 6 months
- Very small review base: only 3 reviews
- On-time shipment rate of 85.7%, which is acceptable but not strong
- Finished Product Inspection information is Insufficient Data
- No provided data on product certifications, quality testing, production capacity, or export markets

Growth potential:
The supplier has strong platform credibility, including 9 years as a Gold Supplier, Trade Assurance support, verified supplier status, and multiple customization-related service tags. If business volume, customer feedback, delivery consistency, and quality inspection transparency improve, the supplier could become a stronger candidate for broader procurement cooperation.